Barzun, My Editor

Helen Hazen’s American Scholar essay on having Jacques Barzun as an editor feels a little strange to me. There’s a definite undercurrent of “Jacques was not only my editor, he was my suitor” (which is all the stranger given the subject matter of her book), and she seems to almost delight in the “punishment” (her word) that he dealt out as her editor.

That said, it’s an interesting look at what it was like to be edited by one of the English language’s most legendary and legendarily finicky practitioners.

But that said, I’m not sure I agree with Hazen’s unambiguous acceptance of the need to blanch her writing of all emotion and illogic:

After a while I got to see that the trouble was that I started with an emotion that, with some pulling, became an idea, but I suffered a weakness in rigorous thinking and was unable to sufficiently elaborate on that idea. Mr. Barzun argued elsewhere that without clear and accurate language we cannot communicate effectively. This was exactly my dilemma. He even recognized the problem early on. His response to the mess of the first draft ended with this prescient admonition:

The only thing I shan’t allow is that your present lack of pattern is the way women think and on that account must be put up with. Even women readers won’t put up with it.

I slowly learned to take the thought one step at a time, to think logically from one point to the next and put those thoughts into clear and effective sentences.

One wonders what would have become of Derrida if Barzun has been his editor.

More from Conversational Reading:

  1. NYRB Editor on Andrey Platonov NYRB Classics editor Edwin Frank discusses Platanov’s The Foundation Pit at the NYRB Classics blog. Much of Frank’s post deals with the language of the...
  2. Editor of Harper's Out The NYT offers competing information as to whether Harper’s editor Rodger Hodge stepped down or was dismissed, but either way he’s been replaced by managing...
  3. Welcome QC Editor Daniel Medin Issue 26 of The Quarterly Conversation, which we just published on Monday, is the first to have contributions from our latest editor, Daniel Medin. (That’s...
  4. Sara Nelson Laid Off as Editor of PW The New York Observer discusses PW’s surprising layoff of Sara Nelson: The New York Times reports the astonishing news that Sara Nelson, the editor-in-chief of...
  5. Stop the Editor Hating! Okay, okay, I know . . . I’ve done it, you’ve done it. At one point in the past five years or so, each and...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.


Criticism Isn't Free


CR is dedicated to thoughtful, in-depth criticism without regard to what's commercially appealing. It takes tens of hours each month to provide this. Please help make this sort of writing sustainable, either with a subscription or a one-time donation. Thank you!





Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Shop though these links = Support this site

Copyright © 2015. Powered by WordPress & Romangie Theme.