Letter Killers Club by Sigizmund Krzhizhanovsky
Over at The Constant Conversation, Matt Jakubowski posts about an, errrr, ignorant experience across the Atlantic:
I wanted to point out the following argument, found at the top of the comments section for the article, which makes a comparison on this topic that I’d never heard before, and frankly don’t know what to make of:
I don’t understand the concern about the survival of independent booksellers. I shop for food at independent retailers (or direct from the producers) because I am interested in the quality, distinctiveness and provenance of meat, fish, cheese, bread, etc. But if I want a particular book, it is the same whether it comes from an independent, Waterstones or Amazon…
Matt goes on to ask for some rebuttals. Here’s one from the comments:
For me–a former bookseller and current publishing person–it comes down to community and distinctiveness. Can I promise that commenter that he’ll have a different experience buying a book from an independent than from a chain? No, but I think it’s likely that if he shops there regularly, and if he’s personable, he will. He’ll become familiar with the staff. He’ll start to take notice of their staff picks and recommended titles, and, if he’s adventurous, he’ll start to get an idea of who on staff has tastes that align with his. He may even find some books that way that he would never have encountered. He’ll likely see fewer tchotchkes and more books, and he’ll likely see more uncommon books. . .
You Might Also Like:
More from Conversational Reading:
- Killing Bookstores Matt Cheney makes an important distinction between why we shop at Amazon and why we shop at brick and mortars: I use the internet to...
- What the People Want Wikirank isn't that bad of a tool for capturing the literary Zeitgeist. Here, for instance, you can see a definite spike in the pageviews for...
- Poor People Via Max, I see that Vollmann’s nonfiction book Poor People is scheduled for release in March of this year. 464 pages . . . a...
- Poor People Vollmann’s newest gets slammed in The New York Times. (make sure to click through to see the downright frightening Vollmann picture they have chosen to...
- The People of Paper Being as I am a fan of books about California, Salvador Plascencia’s The People of Paper sounds like just the thing. In ”The People of...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
The Names by Don DeLillo (1982)
The Box Man by Kobo Abe (1973, English 1974)
Head in Flames by Lance Olsen (2009)
Agaat by Marlene van Niekerk (2006, English 2010)
The Weather Fifteen Years Ago by Wolf Haas (2006, English 2009)
Matt’s point is well-taken, but it might be that while Amazon or what have you can’t replace the community and personality of independent bookstores, book blogs, review sites, goodreads, and the like probably can. That’s a hard one-two combo for bookstores, and this is someone who goes out of his way to patronize them. (perhaps even my phrasing is telling, that I “go out of my way” whereas I suppose the internet is already “in my way.”)