Suddenly, a Knock at the Door

Jacob Silverman with a solid review of Suddenly, a Knock at the Door by Edgar Keret and a nice critique of the whole flash fiction trend.

The problem with flash fiction is that much of it isn’t very good. Boosters like to say that So-and-so packs more into a thousand words than most writers do into a novel, but that’s almost never true—particularly when you consider that time spent with a novel, and all of the mental and emotional investment that that requires, is one of its principal features. Instead, most flash fiction is too brief and self-satisfied to strike more than one note. Often, it’s a joke told too long or a conceit that doesn’t become anything else. It’s literary tokenism, stories to be consumed between commercial breaks.

But back to Etgar Keret, who on his own seems to rehabilitate the genre. For twenty years, Keret has been writing deviously strange, fabulist stories, most of which are only a few pages long. (His closest American analog may be Donald Barthelme.) Keret has also collaborated with artists on graphic novels, written for film and television, and co-directed a very good movie, Jellyfish, with his wife, Shira Geffen. He’s now one of Israel’s most popular artists, and through his books and widely published personal essays, he has increasingly become known to English-speaking audiences.

Like Jacob, I don’t rule out flash fiction entirely, but I am a little suspicious at how it’s been seized at by the “short attention span” crowd.

You Might Also Like:

More from Conversational Reading:

  1. The Movement to Republish Barthelme Back in Issue 12 of The Quarterly Conversation, Dan Green lamented the fact that we can’t read Donald Barthelme any longer as he originally intended:...
  2. Is That Enough Daugherty/Barthelme For You? One of my favorite reviews this issue if John Lingan’s in-depth look at Donald Barthelme via Tracey Daugherty’s recent bio, Hiding Man. John has also...
  3. Barthelme in The New York Review   Lorrie Moore has a nice piece on Donald Barthelme in the current New York Review. The piece doesn't really break any new ground, but...
  4. Say What? McSweeney's is very good at being McSweeney's:...
  5. And Suddenly McSweeney`s Is In My Good Book McSweeney`s ridicules the second-stupidest man in punditry. (Can anyone guess the first?) THOMAS FRIEDMAN EXPLAINS THE ISSUES OF THE DAY It’s clear we’ve entered a...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

1 Comment

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


[…] little poems and proems, and a little flash fiction (stunts that weren’t any more compelling then than they are today). Several of the stories are parodies of science fiction stories: Richard Matheson has a […]

Shop though these links = Support this site

Copyright © 2015. Powered by WordPress & Romangie Theme.