The Omnipotent Critic

I don’t see the point in starting a review with a sentence like this one written by Kyle Minor for Salon:

Eula Biss’ “Notes From No Man’s Land” is the most accomplished book of essays anyone has written or published so far in the 21st century.

Yes, I get it, you really like the book, and you want to find some way of communicating your enthusiasm. That’s fine. But “written or published”? Isn’t that taking things a little too far? So somehow you’re not only able to account for every book of essays that has been published in the last 13 years but also every unpublished manuscript sitting out there?

Again, I get that there’s a lot of enthusiasm for this book, and Minor actually does a good job of making the book sound compelling in the rest of the review, but there are much more defensible ways of saying this.

You Might Also Like:

More from Conversational Reading:

  1. Pamuk Nobel Lecture Cancelled? This is one of the downsides of making a literary award so overtly political. It’s not a minor cost, and it’s one the Nobel commitee...
  2. John Updike: Homophobic Critic Slate resets a 1999 John Updike review in which he pretty clearly defined himself as homophobic (quote below). I bring this up since I've been...
  3. The Critics’ Critic Dalkey Archive, which has acquired William Gaddis’ major books, is also publishing Fire the Bastards! a famous screed against the critics who failed to appreciate...
  4. The Critic In either a promotion of or a warning about book reviewing, Scott McLemee uses 1970s’s The Critic as a lead-in to honor critic Steve Kellman:...
  5. The Critic's Job Dan Green follows up a good post from a couple weeks ago on the critic’s job with this equally insightful one: I do think that...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

1 Comment

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Dontcha know every unpublished manuscript is a worthless piece of crap? Until it gets published, that is; afterwards then it’s great.

Shop though these links = Support this site

Copyright © 2015. Powered by WordPress & Romangie Theme.